What they're not telling you: # Getting An 'A' At Harvard Will Be Tougher Starting In 2027 ## SECTION 1 Harvard University's faculty voted to cap A grades at 20 percent of undergraduate course marks beginning in fall 2027, marking an institutional acknowledgment that grade inflation has eroded academic standards at one of America's most selective universities. Approximately 70 percent of nearly 700 participating professors approved the measure in a Wednesday vote, according to reporting from The Crimson, Harvard's student newspaper. The A cap represents the centerpiece of a broader reform package designed to address what faculty members describe as systemic grade inflation—the documented trend of rising average grades across American higher education institutions over decades, even as standardized test scores and other academic measures have remained relatively flat or declined.
What the Documents Show
Harvard psychology professor Steven Pinker characterized the decision as "a big step in combatting the grade inflation that has been dumbing down our courses, conveying the wrong message to students, and making universities a national laughingstock." Pinker's framing—that grade inflation represents a public credibility crisis—reflects faculty concerns that the devaluation of the A grade has stripped it of meaningful signaling power to employers and graduate programs evaluating candidates. The faculty simultaneously approved a second measure by large majority: replacing GPA rankings with percentile-based systems for determining internal awards and honors. This paired approach suggests faculty architects intended the percentile system to counterbalance potential student anxiety about the A cap. Under percentile ranking, a student's class standing would depend on relative performance rather than absolute grades, potentially protecting top performers even in a compressed grading distribution. A third proposal failed to advance.
Follow the Money
It would have exempted professors teaching on non-traditional grading scales—courses using "unsatisfactory, satisfactory, and satisfactory-plus" frameworks—from the A cap requirement. The rejection of this carve-out indicates faculty preferred a uniform policy rather than categorical exceptions that might have undermined the reform's stated purpose. The Harvard decision carries institutional weight beyond the campus. Political scientist Max Abrams at Northeastern University explicitly noted that peer universities treat Harvard's academic policy shifts as templates for their own institutional decisions. Several scholars quoted in coverage called for other Ivy League institutions to implement similar measures. This cascading influence pattern suggests that if other elite universities follow Harvard's lead, the cumulative effect could reshape grading practices across American higher education—institutions serving roughly 20 million students annually.
What Else We Know
What remains unclear from available sources: how Harvard will enforce compliance, what data initially triggered the 2027 implementation timeline, and whether faculty anticipate student or administrative resistance during the transition period. The Crimson reported the vote outcome but did not publish internal data on current A distribution rates that presumably informed the 20 percent threshold specifically, rather than 15 or 25 percent. --- ## THE TAKE What strikes me most about this story is how little resistance emerged from the institution with the most to lose from transparency about grade inflation—Harvard itself. The pattern here is that elite institutions have created a closed-loop credentialing system where inflated grades persist precisely because they benefit current stakeholders: students receive valuable-seeming transcripts, faculty avoid grade dispute management, and the institution maintains a reputation for rigorous selectivity at admission while delivering grade generosity at exit. Everyone inside the system benefits from the pretense that the current system still signals anything meaningful. Harvard's vote breaks that silence, but only after decades of documented grade inflation already devalued the institution's own degree.
Primary Sources
- Source: ZeroHedge
- Category: Unexplained
- Cross-reference independently — don't take our word for it.
Disclosure: NewsAnarchist aggregates from public records, API feeds (Federal Register, CourtListener, MuckRock, Hacker News), and independent media. AI-assisted synthesis. Always verify primary sources linked above.